| 1980 |
| Life Achievement: | Manly Wade Wellman |
| Best Novel: | Watchtower by Elizabeth A. Lynn |
| Best Short Fiction (tie): | "The Woman Who Loved the Moon" by Elizabeth A. Lynn; "Mackintosh Willy" by Ramsey Campbell |
| Best Anthology/Collection: | Amazons by Jessica Amanda Salmonson |
| Best Artist: | Don Maitz |
| Special Award - Professional: | Donald M. Grant |
| Special Award - Non-Professional: | Fantasy Newsletter (Paul Allen, ed.) |
| Convention Award: | Stephen King |
 |
| 1981 |
| Life Achievement: | C. L. Moore |
| Best Novel: | The Shadow of the Torturer by Gene Wolfe |
| Best Short Fiction: | "The Ugly Chicken" by Howard Waldrop |
| Best Anthology/Collection: | Dark Forces (Kirby McCauley, ed.) |
| Best Artist: | Michael Whelan |
| Special Award - Professional: | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Special Award - Non-Professional: | Pat Cadigan and Arnold Fenner, Shayol |
| Convention Award: | Gahan Wilson |
 |
| 1982 |
| Life Achievement: | Italo Calvino |
| Best Novel: | Little, Big by John Crowley |
| Best Novella: | "The Fire When it Comes" by Parke Godwin |
| Best Short Fiction: | "The Dark Country" by Dennis Etchison |
| Best Anthology/Collection: | Elsewhere (Terri Windling & Mark Arnold, eds.) |
| Best Artist: | Michael Whelan |
| Special Award - Professional: | Edward L. Ferman |
| Special Award - Non-Professional: | Fantasy Newsletter (Robert Collins, ed.) |
| Convention Award: | Joseph Payne Brennan, Roy Krenkel |
 |
| 1983 |
| Life Achievement: | Roald Dahl |
| Best Novel: | Nifft the Lean by Michael Shea |
| Best Novella (tie): | "Confess the Seasons" by Charles L. Grant; "Beyond All Measure" by Karl Edward Wagner |
| Best Short Fiction: | "The Gorgon" by Tanith Lee |
| Best Anthology/Collection: | Nightmare Seasons by Charles L. Grant |
| Best Artist: | Michael Whelan |
| Special Award - Professional: | Donald M. Grant |
| Special Award - Non-Professional: | Whispers (Stuart David Schiff, ed.) |
| Convention Award: | Arkham House |
 |
| 1984 |
| Life Achievement: | L. Sprague de Camp,
Richard Matheson, E. Hoffman Price, Jack Vance, Donald Wandrei |
| Best Novel: | The Dragon Waiting by John M. Ford |
| Best Novella: | "Black Air" by Kim Stanley Robinson |
| Best Short Fiction: | "Elle Est Troi (La Mort)" by Tanith Lee |
| Best Anthology/Collection: | High Spirits by Robertson Davies |
| Best Artist: | Stephen Gervais |
| Special Award - Professional (tie): | Ian and Betty Ballantine;
Joy Chant and George Sharp - The High Kings |
| Special Award - Non-Professional: | Fantasy Tales (Stephen Jones&Daivd A. Sutton, eds.) |
| Convention Award: | Donald M. Grant |
 |
| 1985 |
| Life Achievement: | Theodore Sturgeon |
| Best Novel (tie): | The Bridge of Birds by Barry Hughart; Mythago Wood by Robert Holdstock |
| Best Novella: | "The Unconquered Country" by Geoff Ryman |
| Best Short Fiction: | "Still Life with Scorpion" by Scott Baker |
| Best Anthology/Collection: | Clive Barker's Books of Blood, Vols. I-III by Clive Barker |
| Best Artist: | Edward Gorey |
| Special Award - Professional: | The Mysteries of Harris Burdick by Chris Van Allsburg |
| Special Award - Non-Professional: | Whispers by
Stuart David Schiff |
| Convention Award: | Evangeline Walton |
 |
| 1986 |
| Life Achievement: | Avram Davidson |
| Best Novel: | Song of Kali by Dan Simmons |
| Best Novella: | "Naldelman's God" by T. E. D. Klein |
| Best Short Fiction: | "Paper Dragons" by James Blaylock |
| Best Anthology/Collection: | Imaginary Lands (Robin McKinley, ed.) |
| Best Artist (tie): | Jeff Jones; Thomas Canty |
| Special Award - Professional: | Doubleday -
Pay LoBrutto |
| Special Award - Non-Professional: | Douglas E. Winter |
| Convention Award: | Donald A. Wollheim |
 |
| 1987 |
| Life Achievement: | Jack Finney |
| Best Novel: | Perfume by Patrick Suskind |
| Best Novella: | "Hatrack River" by Orson Scott Card |
| Best Short Fiction: | "Red Light" by David J. Schow |
| Best Anthology/Collection: | Tales of the Quintana Roo by James Tiptree, Jr. |
| Best Artist: | Robert Gould |
| Special Award - Professional: | Favorite Tales from Around the World by Jane Yolen |
| Special Award - Non-Professional (tie): |
Scream Press (Jeff Connor, ed.); Weirdbook (W. Paul Ganley, ed.) |
| Convention Award: | Andre Norton |
 |
| 1988 |
| Life Achievement: | Everett F. Bleiler |
| Best Novel: | Replay by Ken Grimwood |
| Best Novella: | "Buffalo Gals Won't You Come Out Tonight" by Ursula K. Le Guin |
| Best Short Fiction: | "Friends' Best Man" by Jonathan Carroll |
| Best Anthology (tie): | The Architecture of Fear (Kathryn Cramer, Peter D. Pautz, eds.); Dark Descent (David G. Hartwell, ed.) |
| Best Collection: | The Jaguar Hunter by Lucius Shepard |
| Best Artist: | J. K. Potter |
| Special Award - Professional: | David G. Hartwell, Arbor/Tor Anthologies |
| Special Award - Non-Professional (tie): | The Horror Show by David B. Silva; American Fantasy by Robert and Nancy Garcia |
 |
| 1989 |
| Life Achievement: | Evangeline Walton |
| Best Novel: | Koko by Peter Straub |
| Best Novella: | "The Skin Trade" by George R. R. Martin |
| Best Short Fiction: | "Winter Solstice, Camelot Station" by John M. Ford |
| Best Anthology: | The Year's Best Fantasy: First Annual Collection (Ellen Datlow, Terri Windling, eds.) |
| Best Collection (tie): | Angry Candy by Harlan Ellison; Stories From the Old Hotel by Gene Wolfe |
| Best Artist: | Edward Gorey |
| Special Award - Professional (tie): | Robert Weinberg; "A Biographical Dictionary of Science Fiction& Fantasy Artists" by Terri Windling |
| Special Award - Non-Professional: | Pulphouse (Kristine Kathryn Rusch, Dean Wesley Smith (eds.) |
 |