| 1987 |
| Novels: | Live Girls by Ray Garton |
| Misery by Stephen King |
| Swan Song by Robert R. Mccammon |
| Unassigned Territory by Ken Nunn |
| Ash Wednesday by Chet Williamson |
| First Novel: | The Damnation Game by Clive Barker |
| The Manse by Lisa Cantrell |
| Slob by Rex Miller |
| The Harvest Bride by Tony Richards |
| Excavation by Steve Rasnic Tem |
 |
| 1988 |
| Novels: | The Silence of the Lambs by Thomas Harris |
| Stinger by Robert R. Mccammon |
| Black Wind by F. Paul Wilson |
| The Drive-In by Joe R. Lansdale |
| Queen of the Damned by Anne Rice |
| Flesh by Richard Laymon |
| First Novel: | The Suiting by Kelley Wilde & Michael Paine |
| Resurrection, Inc. by Kevin J. Anderson |
| Deliver Us From Evil by Alan Lee Harris |
| Demon Night by J. Michael Straczynski |
| Fear Book by John L. Byrne |
 |
| 1989 |
| Novels: | Carrion Comfort by Dan Simmons |
| Geek Love by Katherine Dunn |
| In a Dark Dream by Charles L. Grant |
| Midnight by Dean R. Koontz |
| The Wolf's Hour by Robert R. Maccammon |
| First Novel | The Dwelling by Tom Elliot |
| Goat Dance by Douglas Clegg |
| Laying the Music to Rest by Dean Wesley Smith |
| The Lilith Factor by Jean Paiva |
| Sunglasses After D by Nancy A. Collins |
 |
| 1990 |
| Novels: | Funland by Richard Laymon |
| Mine by Robert R. Mccammon |
| Reign by Chet Williamson |
| Savage Season by Joe R. Lansdale |
| First Novel | Blood of the Children by Alan Rodgers |
| Dark Father by Tom Piccirilli |
| Nightblood by T. Chris Martindale |
| The Revelation by Bentley Little |
 |
| 1991 |
| Novels: | The M.D. by Thomas M. Disch |
| Needful Things by Stephen King |
| The Dark Tower III--The Waste Lands by Stephen King |
| Boy's Life by Robert R. Mccammon |
| Summer of Night by Dan Simmons |
| First Novels: | Winter Scream by Chris Curry & L. Dean James |
| Wilderness by Dennis Danvers |
| The Cipher by Kathe Koja |
| Unearthed by Ashley McConnell |
| Prodigal by Melanie Tem |
 |
| 1992 |
| Novels: | Homecoming by Matthew Costello |
| Deathgroup by Brian Hodge |
| Hideaway by Dean Koontz |
| Blood of the Lamb by Thomas F. Monteleone |
| Children of the Night by Dan Simmons |
| First Novels: | Lost Souls by Poppy Z. Brite |
| Beauty by Brian D'amato |
| Sineater by Elizabeth Massie |
| Less Than Human by Gary Raisor |
| The Holy Terror by Wayne Allen Sallee |
 |
| 1993 |
| Novels: | Anno Dracula by Kim Newman |
| Blackburn by Bradley Denton |
| Drawing Blood by Poppy Z. Brite |
| The Summoning by Bentley Little |
| The Throat by Peter Straub |
| First Novels: | Afterage by Yvonne Navarro |
| Created By by Richard Christian Matheson |
| Suckers by Anne Billson |
| The Thread That Binds The Bones by Nina Kiriki Hoffman |
| Wet Work by Philip Nutman |
 |
| 1994 |
| Novels: | The Alienist by Caleb Carr |
| From the Teeth of Angels by Jonathan Carroll |
| Dead in the Water by Nancy Holder |
| Insomnia by Stephen King |
| The Butcher Boy by Patrick McCabe |
| First Novel: | Grave Markings by Michael Arnzen |
| The Black Mariah by Jay R. Bonansinga |
| Deadweight by Robert Devereaux |
| Near Death by Nancy Kilpatrick |
| Collection | The Early Fears by Robert Bloch |
| Writer Of the Purple Rage by Joe R. Lansdale |
| The Flesh Artist by Lucy Taylor |
| Born Bad by Andrew Vachss |
| Novelette: | The Scent of Vinegar by Robert Bloch |
| Sometimes, In the Rain by Charles L. Grant |
| The Alchemy Of the Throat by Brian Hodge |
| Buba Ho-Tep by Joe R. Lansdale |
| The Siren of Swan Quarter by William Trotter |
| Short Story: | Cafe Endless: Spring Rain by Nancy Holder |
| The Box by Jack Ketchum |
| Mr. Torso by Edward Lee |
| Things Of Which We Do Not Speak by Lucy Taylor |
 |
| 1995 |
| Novels: | Widow by Billie Sue Mosiman |
| Deadrush by Yvonne Navarro |
| Zombie by Joyce Carol Oates |
| Bone Music by Alan Rodgers |
| First Novels: | Diary of a Vampire by Gary Bowen |
| The Between by Tananarive Due |
| Madeleine's Ghost by Robert Giardi |
| The Safety of Unknown Cities by Lucy Taylor |
| Wyrm Wolf by Edo Van Belkom |
| Novellette: | Baby Girl Diamond by Adam-Troy Castro |
| Lunch At the Gotham Cafe by Stephen King |
| Looking For Mr. Flip by Thomas F. Monteleone |
| Lover Doll by Wayne Allen Sallee |
| Short Story: | Becky Lives by Harry Crews |
| Chatting With Anubis by Harlan Ellison |
| The Bungalow House by Thomas Ligotti |
| Death of the Novels by William Browning Spencer |
| Collection: | The Panic Hand by Jonathan Carroll |
| Cages by Ed Gorman |
| The Black Carousel by Charles Grant |
| Strange Highways by Dean Koontz |
| Non-Fiction: | The Supernatural Index by Mike Ashley & William Contento |
| Psycho: Behind The Scenes by Janet Leigh & Chrsitopher Nickens |
| An Encyclopedia Of Claims, Frauds, And Hoaxes of the Occult and Supernatural by James Randi |
| Immoral Tales: European Sex and Horror Movies 1956-1984 by Cathal Tohill & Pete Tombs |
| Life Achievement | Harlan Ellison |
 |
| 1996 |
| Novels: | Exquisite Corpse by Poppy Z. Brite |
| Crota by Owl Going Back (a.k.a. Donald I Fine) |
| The Green Mile by Stephen King |
| The Hellfire Club by Peter Straub |
| First Novels: | Flute Song by Donald Burleson |
| Crota by Owl Going Back |
| Horror Show by Greg Kihn |
| Celestial Dogs by Jay Russell |
| Deah Heat by Del Stone |
| Novellete/Novella: | Kilroy Was Here by Jack Cady |
| The Thing from Lover's Lane by Nancy Collins |
| The Red Tower by Thomas Ligotti |
| Brimstone and Salt by S.P. Somtow |
| Short Story: | Metalica by Patricia D. Cacek |
| The Slobbering Tongue That Ate the Frightfully Huge Woman by Robert Devereaux |
| The Secret Shih Tan by Graham Masterton |
| The House of Mourning by Brian Stableford |
| Plan 10 from outer Space by Karl Edward Wagner |
| The Cherry Meadow Massacre by Sidney Williams |
| Collection: | The Convulsion Factory by Brian Hodge |
| The Nightmare Factory by Thomas Ligotti |
| Shadow Dreams by Elizabeth Massie |
| With Wounds Still West by Wayne Allen Sallee |
| The Pavilion of Frozen Women by S.P. Somtow |
| Non-Fiction: | Bram Stoker: A Biography of the Author of Dracula by Barbara Belford |
| The Great Pulp Heroes by Don Hutchison |
| The Illustrated Werewolf Movie Guide by Stephen Jones |
| H.P. Lovecraft: A Life by S.T. Joshi |
| V is for Vampire by David Skal |
| Life Achievement: | Ira Levin; Forrest J Ackerman |
 |
| 1997 |
| Novel: | Children of the Dusk by Janet Berliner & George Guthridge |
| The Church of Dead Girls by Stephen Dobyns |
| My Soul to Keep by Tananarive Due |
| Earthquake Weather by Tim Powers |
| First Novel: | Lives of the Monster Dogs by Kirsten Bakis |
| The Art of Arrow Cutting by Stephen Dedman |
| Hungry Eyes by Barry Hoffman |
| Drawn to the Grave by Mary Ann Mitchell |
| The Inquisitor by Mary Murrey |
| Novellete: | The Word by Ramsey Campbell |
| Everything's Evenutal by Stephen King |
| The Big Blow by Joe R. Lansdale |
| Coppola's Dracula by Kim Newman |
| The Zombies of Madison County by Douglas E. Winter |
| Short Story: | I Am Infinite, I Contain Multitudes by Douglas Clegg |
| A Plague on Both Your Houses by Scott Edelman |
| Madame Babylon by Brian Hodge |
| Rat Food by Edo van Belkom & David Nickle |
| Collection: | Things Left Behind by Gary A. Braunbevck |
| The Throne of Bones by Brian McNaughton |
| Painted in Blood by Lucy Taylor |
| Exorcisms and Ecstasies by Karl Edward Wagner |
| Non-Fiction: | The Encyclopedia of Fantasy (John Clute & John Grant, eds.) |
| The Hammer Story by Marcus Hearn & Alan Barnes |
| Video Watchdog by Tim Lucas |
| Dean Koontz: A Writer's Biography by Katherine Ramsland |
| Dark Thoughts: On Writing by Stanley Wiater |
| Lifetime Achievement: | William Blatty |
| Jack Williamson |
 |
| 1998 |
| Novel: | Bag of Bones by Stephen King |
| Fear Nothing by Dean Koontz |
| Darker Angels by S.P. Somtow |
| Fog Heart by Thomas Tessier |
| First Novels: | Night Prayers by P.D. Cacek |
| The Symbiotic Fascination by Caitlin R. Kiernan |
| Silk by Caitlin R. Kiernan |
| Dawn Song by Michael Marano |
| Novellete: | Leavings by P.D. Cacek |
| As Above, So Below by Brian Hodge |
| What Would You Do for Love by John Shirley |
| Mr. Clubb and Mr. Cuff by Peter Straub |
| Short Story: | Blues-Born by Tina Jens |
| Autopsy Room Four by Stephen King |
| The Dead Boy At Your Window by Bruce Holland Rogers |
| The Rug by Edo van Balkom |
| Collection: | Leavings by P.D. Cacek |
| Smoke and Mirrors by Neil Gaiman |
| Black Butterflies by John Shirley |
| The Cleft and Other Odd Tales by Gahan Wilson |
| Anthology: | Robert Bloch's Psychos by Robert Bloch, ed. |
| The Best of Cemetary Dance by Richard Chizmar, ed. |
| The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: 11th Annual Collection by Ellen Datlow & Terri Windling, eds. |
| Horrors! 365 Scary Stories (Stefan Dziemianowicz, Martin H. Greenberg & Robert Weinberg, eds.) |
| Non-Fiction: | Gothic Horror: A Reader's Guide for Poe to King and Beyond by Clive Bloom, ed. |
| The Science of the X-Files by Jeanne Cavelos |
| DarkEcho Newsletter, Vol. 5 #1-50 by Paula Guran, ed. |
| A Writer's Tale by Richard Laymon |
| Illustrated Narrative: | No Award |
| Sergio Aragones' Dia de Las Muertos by Sergio Aragones & Mark Evanier |
| Preacher by Garth Ennis |
| The Son of Man by Garth Ennis |
| The Dreaming: Trial and Error by Len Wein |
| Screenplay | Gods and Monsters by BillCondon |
| Fallen by Nicholas Kazan |
| Somehow, Satan Got Behind Me (Episode of Millennium) by Darin Morgan |
| Dark City by Alex Proyas |
| Work for Young Readers: | Bigger Than Death by Nancy Etchemendy |
| Eerie Indiana: The Dollhouse that Time Forgot by Mike Ford |
| Buffy, the Vampire Slayer: The Angel Chronicles by Nancy Holder |
| The X-Files: Hungry Ghosts by Ellen Steiber |
| Other Media: | No Award |
| Universal Horror (TV documentary) by Kevin Brownlow, Prod. |
| The Misfits: American Psycho (music video) by John Fafiero, Prod./Dir. |
| John Carpenter's Vampires (soundtrack) by John Carpenter, Composer |
| Gothic at Midnight: A Tribute to the Master of the Macabre (audio anthology) by Joshua Kane |
| 1999 |
| Novel: | Mr. X by Peter Straub |
| Darker Than Night by Owl Goingback |
| Hannibal by Thomas Harris |
| Low Men in Yellow Coats by Stephen King |
| Hexes by Tom Piccirilli |
| First Novels: | Wither by J.G. Passarella |
| Widow's Walk by Steve Beal |
| Every Dead Thing by John Connolly |
| King Rat by China Miéville |
| Long Fiction: | Five Days in April by Brian A. Hopkins |
| Mad Dog Summer by Joe R. Lansdale |
| Dread in the Beast by Charlee Jacob |
| Right to Life by Jack Ketchum |
| Short Fiction: | After Shock by F. Paul Wilson |
| The Grave by P.D. Cacek |
| The Entertainment by Ramsey Campbell |
| Halloween Street by Steve Rasnic Tem |
| Collection: | The Nightmare Chronicles by Douglas Clegg |
| Death Drives a Semi by Edo van Belkom |
| Hearts in Atlantis by Stephen King |
| Deep into that Darkness Peering by Tom Piccirilli |
| Anthology: | 999: New Stories of Horror and Suspense, Al Sarrantonio, ed. |
| The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror, 11th Annual Collection, Ellen Datlow & Terri Windling, eds. |
| The Mammoth Book of Best New Horror 10, Stephen Jones, ed. |
| The Last Continent: New Tales of Zothique, John Pelan, ed. |
| Non-Fiction: | Darkecho Newsletter, Paula Guran, ed. |
| The Essential Monster Movie Guide by Stephen Jones |
| Vincent Price: A Daughter's Biography by Victoria Price |
| Hellnotes, David B. Silva & Paul F. Olson, eds. |
| Illustrated Narrative: | The Sandman: The Dream Hunters by Neil Gaiman |
| Jonah Hex: Shadows West #1 by Joe R. Lansdale |
| Hellboy: Box Full of Evil by Mike Mignola |
| Faust: Book of M by David Quinn |
| Screenplay | The Sixth Sense by M. Night Shyamalan |
| The Green Mile by Frank Darabont |
| The Blair Witch Project by Daniel Myrick & Eduardo Sanchez |
| Hush (episode of Buffy, The Vampire Slayer) by Joss Whedon |
| Work for Young Readers: | Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban by J.K. Rowling |
| Something Lumber This Way Comes by Joe R. Lansdale |
| Creepy Susie & 13 Other Tragic Tales for Troubled Children by Angus Oblong |
| Other Media: | I Have no Mouth and I must Scream (audio) by Harlan Ellison |
| Masters of Terror (website) by Andy Fairclough |
| Gothic Net (website) by Seth Lindberg |
| Conspiracies (audio CD), WyrdSisterS ProductionS |
| Specialty Press: | Ash-Tree Press, Christopher & Barbara Roden |
| Lifetime Achievement: | Edward Gorey |
| Charles L. Grant |
| 2000 |
| Novel: | The Traveling Vampire Show by Richard Laymon |
| The Indifference of Heaven by Gary A. Braunbeck |
| Silent Children by Ramsey Campbell |
| The Licking Valley Coon Hunter's Club by Brian A. Hopkins |
| The Deceased by Tom Piccirilli |
| First Novels: | The Licking Valley Coon Hunters Club by Brian A. Hopkins |
| Nailed by the Heart by Simon Clark |
| House of Leaves by Mark Z. Danielewski |
| Run by Douglas E. Winter |
| Long Fiction: | The Man on the Ceiling by Steve Rasnic Tem & Melanie Tem |
| Riding the Bullet by Stephen King |
| In Shock by Joyce Carol Oates |
| God Screamed and Screamed, Then I Ate Him by Lawrence P. Santoro |
| Short Fiction: | Gone by Jack Ketchum |
| Dead Cat Bounce by Gerard Daniel Houarner |
| Fallen Angel by Robert J. Sawyer |
| Mexican Moon by Karen E. Taylor |
| Collection: | Magic Terror: Seven Tales by Peter Straub |
| Up, Out of Cities the BLow Hot and Cold by Charlee Jacob |
| Wind Over Heaven and Other Dark Tales by Bruce Holland Rogers |
| City Fishing by Steve Rasnic Tem |
| Anthology: | The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: Thirteenth Annual Collection edited by Ellen Datlow & Terri Windling |
| Brainbox: The Real Horror edited by Steve Eller |
| Extremes: Fantasy & Horror from the Ends of the Earth edited by Brian A. Hopkins |
| Bad News edited by Richard Laymon |
| Non-Fiction: | On Writing by Stephen King |
| Hellnotes by David B. Silva & Paul F. Olson |
| At the Foot of the Story Tree: The Fiction of Peter Straub by Bill Sheehan |
| Horror of the 20gth Century by Robert Weinberg |
| Illustrated Narrative: | The League of Extraordinary Gentleman by Alan Moore |
| Red Romance by Joe R. Lansdale |
| Spuds by Bernie Wrightson |
| Cable 79-84 by Robert Weinberg |
| Screenplay | Shadow of the Vampire by Steven Katz |
| Requiem for a Dream by Darren Aronofsky & Hubert Selby, Jr. |
| The Cell by Mark Protosevich |
| Unbreakable by M. Night Shyamalan |
| Pitch Black by David Twohy and Ken & Jim Wheat |
| Work for Young Readers: | The Power of Un by Nancy Etchemendy |
| Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire by J.K. Rowling |
| Be Afraid! edited by Edo van Belkom |
| The Christmas Thingy by F. Paul Wilson |
| Other Media: | Chiaroscuro a website by Patricia Lee Macomber, Steve Eller, Sandra Kasturi and Brett A. Savory |
| Twilight Tales Reading Series by Tina L. Jens & Andrea Dubnick |
| Back to the Black Lagoon by David J. Skal |
| Gothic.Net (website) by Mehitobel Wilson |
| Poetry Collection: | A Student of Hell by Tom Piccirilli |
| Paratabloids by Michael A. Arnzen |
| The Complete Accursed Wives by Bruce Boston |
| Burial Plot in Sagittarius by Sandy DeLuca |
| Specialty Press: | Subterranean Press, William K. Schafer |
| Lifetime Achievement: | Nigel Kneale |
| Trustees Hammer Award: | Nancy Etchemendy |
| The Richard Laymon Award (President's Award): | Judi Rohrig and Kathy Ptacek
|